The Election Commission of India’s (ECI) Extraordinary Seriously Amendment (SIR) of appointive rolls, propelled on June 24, has touched off a furious political and legitimate fight, with fears of broad voter disappointment approaching huge.
The work out, pointed at upgrading Bihar’s voter list ahead of the up and coming Get together races, has drawn sharp feedback for its documentation necessities, tight due dates, and avoidance of broadly held personality reports like Aadhaar, voter ID, and apportion cards.
Bhagalpur, a memorable city on the banks of the Ganges, is a microcosm of Bihar’s complex socio-political scene. With its differing populace of urban dealers, provincial ranchers, and vagrant laborers, the city reflects the state’s challenges of destitution, movement, and constrained get to to documentation.
The ECI’s SIR requires all 7.9 crore voters in Bihar to yield count shapes, with 4.96 crore voters enrolled after January 1, 2003, requiring to give extra archives to demonstrate their date and put of birth. For those born after 1987, confirmation of their parents’ character is moreover required, unless their guardians were recorded in the 2003 rolls.
What Are My Voting Rights in Bihar 2025 Assembly Election?
The ECI has indicated a list of 11 records, such as birth certificates, identifications, and caste certificates, but outstandingly avoids Aadhaar, voter ID, and apportion cards, which are among the most available forms of distinguishing proof for Bihar’s destitute and underestimated communities.
Related Article: Bihar Election 2025: Polling Day Do’s & Don’ts
The prohibition of these archives has started shock, especially among minimized bunches, counting Planned Castes (SCs), Planned Tribes (STs), and Muslims. In the city’s swarmed ghettos and provincial edges, numerous inhabitants need the reports required by the ECI.
“I have an Aadhaar card and an apportionment card, but no birth certificate,” said Rani Devi, a 45-year-old day-by-day wage laborer in Bhagalpur’s Nathnagar zone. “How am I supposed to demonstrate I’m a citizen? I’ve voted in each race since I was 18. Presently they’re saying I might lose my vote.” Rani’s story is not unique.
27-year-old Shivam Kumar, who has three brothers, says all four of them have voter ID cards. They all have voted in the final Lok Sabha decisions. But, when it comes to joining archives in SIR, he, as it were, has his 10th course marksheet.
The other three brothers don’t indeed have that, as they didn’t go for higher tutoring. They don’t have any of the 11 required records either. This has put the family in a position of frailty with respect to their voting rights and citizenship.
With Bihar’s tall destitution rates and noteworthy out-migration, assessed at 1.76 crore individuals between 2003 and 2024, numerous inhabitants, particularly the destitute and minorities, battle to deliver the required paperwork.
In Kadwa Diyara, a flood-prone island on the Ganges in Bhagalpur, the SIR has cleared out inhabitants like Savita Devi, a 38-year-old dowager, in a state of lose hope. Savita, who lives in a unassuming mud house with her three children, misplaced most of her belonging, counting basic records, amid the obliterating surges of 2023.
Whatever records I had, they all were washed absent when the waterway came into our home,” she related. “I overseen to get a unused Aadhaar, but the BLO says it’s not sufficient. I don’t have a birth certificate or any other papers they want. Rani and Savita have voted in the past common and gathering decisions since they were qualified, but presently fear being struck off the voter list.
The surges, a repeating danger in Kidwa Diara, have cleared out numerous inhabitants in comparable binds, with no get to to the reports required by the ECI. Savita’s endeavors to explore the ECI’s online entrance have been worthless, as the closest cyber café is a watercraft ride absent in Naugachia, and network is unreliable.
The Pinnacle Court Hearing
The Preeminent Court’s hearing on July 10 advertised a glint of trust. A seat comprising Judges Sudhanshu Dhulia and Joymalya Bagchi denied to remain the SIR but coordinated the ECI to consider counting Aadhaar, voter ID, and proportion cards as substantial archives for voter confirmation.
The court famous that the ECI’s list of 11 archives was “not exhaustive” and emphasized that barring broadly held records like Aadhaar was risky, particularly given its utilize in other government forms like getting caste certificates.
The court too addressed the timing of the SIR, inquiring why it was being conducted so near to the decisions and why it showed up to center on citizenship confirmation, a obligation ordinarily beneath the Domestic Ministry’s domain. The ECI was coordinated to record a counter-affidavit by July 21, with the another hearing planned for July 28, some time recently the draft voter list is distributed on Eminent 1.
The Incomparable Court’s mediation has been hailed by restriction pioneers as a step toward inclusivity. Congress MP KC Venugopal called it a “relief for democracy,” communicating trust that the ECI would notice the court’s recommendation. RJD MP Manoj Jha reverberated this opinion, expressing, The Preeminent Court has appeared the way of consideration in the midst of people’s developing fear of exclusion.
However, the court’s refusal to end the SIR has cleared out numerous on edge, as the July 26 due date for submitting count shapes looms. The tight timeline, combined with the ECI’s prerequisite for narrative verification, has fueled fears that millions might lose voting rights, especially in minimized communities.
People Behind SIR: The BLOs of Bihar
In Bhagalpur, the SIR has set colossal weight on Booth Level Officers (BLOs), the grassroots laborers entrusted with conducting door-to-door confirmation. With 77,895 BLOs along with 20,603 recently named BLOs and other race authorities, over 4 lakh volunteers who are supporting the elderly.
PwD, debilitated and defenseless populaces along with the 1.56 lakh proactive constrain of Booth Level Specialists (BLAs) who have been designated by all perceived political parties, the ECI is depending intensely on these authorities to guarantee the exercise’s success.
Till July 10, a add up to of 5,22,44,956 Count Shapes, which is 66.16% of the add up to of 7,89,69,844 (about 7.90 crore) existing voters in Bihar, have been collected. The balloters still have 15 more days cleared out to yield the form. Is bihar bandh today?
In Bhagalpur’s thickly populated zones like Kahalgaon and Pirpainti, BLOs are battling to cover thousands of family units inside the stipulated time allotment. We’re working day and night, but it’s incomprehensible to confirm each voter legitimately in such a brief time,” a BLO from Bhagalpur’s Barari town said. Many individuals don’t have the reports, and a few don’t indeed get it what we’re inquiring for. It takes time to make them get it why this prepare is being carried out and how they can yield the forms.
The ECI’s communication technique has included to the perplexity. Front-page promotions have been distributed in Patna daily papers, encouraging voters to yield shapes indeed without the required archives, expressing that Discretionary Enlistment Officers (EROs) may confirm qualification through nearby examination or other prove. This move, seen as a reaction to resistance weight, was met with skepticism.
The Legislative Issues Over Sir
The political aftermath from the SIR has been dangerous. On July 9, Rahul Gandhi and Tejashwi Yadav driven a enormous dissent walk in Patna, joined by pioneers from the INDIA coalition, counting CPI(ML) Liberation’s Dipankar Bhattacharya, CPI’s D Raja, and Vikassheel Insaan Party’s Mukesh Sahani. The walk, which pointed to reach the ECI’s office in Patna, was ceased close the Shaheed Smarak, with police conveying overwhelming powers to keep up order.
The Resistance called for a statewide “Bihar bandh 2025” on the same day, disturbing street and rail activity in locale like Araria, Purnia, Katihar, and Muzaffarpur. Dissidents burned tires and blocked National Thruway, blaming the ECI of endeavoring to stifle votes from underestimated bunches.
SIR is not as it were an endeavor to take your vote but too your future,” Rahul Gandhi said, holding a duplicate of the Structure amid the challenge. Tejashwi Yadav went encourage, charging that the ECI was acting as an “arm of a political party” and addressing whether two individuals from Gujarat”, an clear reference to Prime Serve Narendra Modi and Domestic Serve Amit Shah, would choose Bihar’s voter eligibility.
The Opposition’s allegations are established in concerns that the SIR may excessively influence voters impossible to back the administering National Equitable Collusion (NDA). In Seemanchal locale, which has a critical Muslim populace, fears of prohibition are especially intense. A clause in the SIR rules enabling EROs to allude “suspected remote nationals” to specialists beneath the Citizenship Act, 1955, has raised alerts almost potential focusing on of minorities.
This feels like a backdoor NRC, said an extremist from Patna, on the condition of secrecy. Many Muslims in Bihar don’t have birth certificates or arrive records. If their names are expelled, they will lose their voice. The restriction has pointed to the ECI’s choice to prohibit Aadhaar, which is broadly utilized by minorities and the destitute, as prove of an exclusionary agenda.
Rahul Gandhi Addresses Supporters in Patna on the Day of Bihar Bandh
The NDA, driven by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), has rejected these claims as “absolutely false.” BJP’s Rajiv Pratap Rudy contended that the ECI’s command to reexamine appointive rolls is protected and fundamental to evacuate non-citizens and copy passages. “The resistance is politicizing a schedule process,” said BJP pioneer Ravi Shankar Prasad.
The ECI has advocated the SIR by citing fast urbanization, relocation, and the consideration of ineligible voters since the final seriously amendment in 2003. In any case, faultfinders like individuals of the Affiliation for Majority rule Changes (ADR) contend that the work out is exceptional in its scale and timing, and that it is a de novo planning of the appointive roll, successfully junking the existing one, which was overhauled as as of late as January this year.
The ADR, along with other applicants like Yogendra Yadav, Mahua Moitra, and Manoj Jha, had challenged the SIR in the Incomparable Court, contending that it damages principal rights beneath Articles 14, 19, 21, and 326. What are the new rules for voters on Bihar election polling day?
The petitions highlighted the chance of disappointing over 3 crore voters, especially those from marginalized communities who need the required archives. Senior advocates like Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Kapil Sibal have called the SIR a “citizenship screening” workout, contending that the burden of verification ought to lie with the ECI, not voters. Disenfranchising even one qualified voter influences the level playing field and hits the essential structure of democracy,” Singhvi told the court.
In Bhagalpur, the fear of disappointment is discernable. Vagrant laborers, who frame a critical parcel of the city’s populace, are especially powerless. Numerous have moved to cities like Delhi and Mumbai for work, making it troublesome to return and yield shapes by the due date. I’m in Mumbai working as a driver,” said Rajesh Paswan, a Bhagalpur local, over a phone call. How can I come back to yield a frame? And what reports? I as it were have my Aadhaar.
Blos Disseminate Count Shapes to Voters in Bhagalpur
The contention has, moreover, drawn consideration to the ECI’s conflicting position on Aadhaar. Whereas the ECI has truly acknowledged Aadhaar for voter enrollment beneath Shape 6.
Its prohibition from the SIR’s archive list has perplexed many. “For a long time, this nation has gone insane saying Aadhaar, Aadhaar, and presently you won’t acknowledge it for identification?” senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan inquired amid the Incomparable Court hearing.
The ECI’s direct contention was that Aadhaar is not verification of citizenship, a point repeated by previous CEC Ashok Lavasa. In any case, faultfinders counter that the 11 acknowledged archives, like caste certificates and arrival records, are, moreover, not authoritative verification of citizenship, making the prohibition of Aadhaar arbitrary.
As the July 26 due date approaches, Bihar’s inhabitants are dashing against time. In provincial ranges, where education rates are low and accessto archives is constrained, the SIR has made an environment of fear.
People are stressed they’ll lose not only their vote but also their proportions and benefits too,” said Anil Kumar, a social laborer in Bhagalpur’s Naugachia region. The opposition’s affirmations of a broader trick to strip underestimated bunches of their rights have resounded with numerous people, especially in the wake of the Maharashtra races, where comparative concerns were raised.
