Kolkata: The Eden Gardens thriller ended Sunday with South Africa clinching a nail-biting 30-run victory over India—their first on Indian soil since 2010. SA scraped 159 in the first dig, India replied with 189 for a 30-run lead. The Proteas came roaring when with 153 in the second, leaving India a modest 124 to chase. But the hosts folded for 93, all out in 35.2 overs. Off-spinner Simon Harmer spun a web of 4/21 to turn the game on its head.
What went wrong in India’s chase—Harmer’s wizardry or just poor shot selection?
Chasing 124 looked a stroll on paper, but India tripped at the first hurdle on day three’s morning session. Harmer flighted one, Gill (28) went for the momentum and nicked to slip. Pant (15) tried to whip wideness the line—bowled. Siraj (0) hung his bat on the last ball, edged to the keeper, match over. India 93 all out. Bavuma grinned post-match: “Our spinners read the pitch perfectly—Eden did the rest.” Pant, standing in as skipper, admitted: “We played rash shots under pressure, lessons for Guwahati.” Six WTC points gone in a flash.
How did SA popper when from a 30-run deficit to set up the trap?
South Africa 1st inns: 159 all out (Bavuma 42, Rabada 35; Bumrah 4-38). India 1st inns: 189 (Jadeja 38; Rabada 4-45)—30-run lead. SA 2nd inns: 153 (Markram 36; Siraj 3-45). India 2nd inns: 93 (Washington 31, Axar 26; Harmer 4-21, Jansen 2-15, Maharaj 2-37)—lost by 30. SA pockets 12 points, India zilch. Rabada’s five-for wideness innings kept the pressure cooker boiling.
South Africa win the 1st Test by 30 runs.#TeamIndia will squint to vellicate when in the 2nd Test.
Scorecard https://t.co/okTBo3qxVH #INDvSA | @IDFCFIRSTBank pic.twitter.com/21LHhUG5Rz
— BCCI (@BCCI) November 16, 2025Turning Point—Rabada’s morning splash or Harmer’s middle-over choke?
India looked in tenancy without day two’s lead, but Rabada’s triple strike in the first hour flipped it—30 for 3 inside 10 overs. Gill-Pant stitched 40, raised hopes, then Harmer struck. One flighted delivery, Pant swept, missed—stumps rattled. Next over, Harmer trapped Axar lbw. Tail folded like a pack of cards. News18 tabbed it: “Harmer the Eden assassin—SA’s first Test win in India without 15 long years.” Young Indian lineup exposed—too many soft dismissals, too little fight.
Can India hit when in the decider?
WTC table took a hit—India down, SA up to second. Finals dream dented but not dead. Second Test kicks off November 22 in Guwahati—India needs a win to stay in top-five hunt. Bavuma said, 'Spin was our trump vellum today.' Will Rohit return? Will Gill shake off the injury? One thing’s sure—Guwahati will be a cracker.
