When it comes to selecting a luxury SUV in the Indian market, the MG Hectorand the Tata Harrier are two strong candidates that provide a combination of style, performance, and modern amenities. Both vehicle models are available in the market. On the other hand, safety and comfort are two of the most important aspects that should be considered while making a purchase selection. In this comprehensive comparison, we will examine how these two SUVs perform in terms of safety features, build quality, ride comfort, and cabin ergonomicsin order to assist you in making an educated decision.
1. Safety Comparison: Which SUV is Safer?
Crash Test Ratings
Safety begins with structural integrity, and both theMG HectorandTata Harrierhave been designed with high-strength steel to ensure passenger protection.
-
Tata Harrier: The Harrier has scored a5-star safety ratingin Global NCAP crash tests (2023), making it one of the safest SUVs in India. It comes with a robustOmega Arcplatform derived from Land Rover’s D8 architecture, ensuring excellent crashworthiness.
-
MG Hector: The Hector has not been tested by Global NCAP yet, but it is built with a high percentage of high-strength steel and features a reinforced body structure for impact protection.
Verdict: The Harrier has a proven safety record with a 5-star rating, giving it an edge over the Hector.
Airbags and Safety Features
Both SUVs come with a host of active and passive safety features, but there are some differences.
Tata Harrier:
- Standard6 airbags(dual front, side, and curtain)
- Electronic Stability Program (ESP)andTraction Control
- Hill Hold ControlandHill Descent Control
- ISOFIX child seat mounts
- Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
- 360-degree camera(in higher variants)
MG Hector:
- 6 airbags(dual front, side, and curtain)
- Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
- Hill Hold Control
- Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
- Rear parking sensors with camera
- Blind Spot Detection(in higher variants)
Verdict: Both SUVs are well-equipped, but the Harrier’s360-degree cameraandHill Descent Controlgive it a slight advantage in safety tech.
Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS)
One area where theMG Hectorpulls ahead isADAS (Advanced Driver Assistance Systems), available in the top variants.
MG Hector ADAS Features:
- Forward Collision Warning
- Autonomous Emergency Braking (AEB)
- Lane Departure Warning
- Adaptive Cruise Control
- Rear Cross Traffic Alert
TheTata Harrierdoes not offer ADAS, which means the Hector has an upper hand inpreventive safety technology.
Verdict: Ifautonomous safety tech is a priority, the Hector is the better choice.
2. Comfort Comparison: Which SUV Offers a Better Ride?
Suspension and Ride Quality
A comfortable ride depends largely on suspension tuning and chassis dynamics.
Tata Harrier:
- Uses aHydraulic Suspension Setup(instead of gas-filled shock absorbers)
- Independent front suspensionandsemi-independent rear suspension
- Tuned for a balance between comfort and stability
- Better at absorbing bumps but can feel slightly stiff on rough roads
MG Hector:
- MacPherson Strut front suspensionandmulti-link rear suspension
- Softer suspension tuning for a plush ride
- Better at filtering out road noise and vibrations
- Slightly more body roll in corners compared to the Harrier
Verdict: TheHector offers a plusher ride, while theHarrier feels more planted at high speeds.
Seat Comfort and Ergonomics
Both SUVs offer premium interiors, but seat comfort varies.
Tata Harrier:
- Leatherette upholstery(higher variants)
- Wider and more supportive seats
- Adjustable driver seat (8-way power-adjustable in top variants)
- Rear seat recline functionfor added comfort
- Slightlyfirmer cushioningfor long-drive support
MG Hector:
- Leather seats(in higher variants)
- Softer cushioningfor short-distance comfort
- Ventilated front seats(in top variants)
- Rear seats lack reclinebut offer good legroom
- Panoramic sunroofadds to the airy feel
Verdict: TheHarrier has better long-drive comfort, while theHector offers more luxury featureslike ventilated seats and a sunroof.
Cabin Space and Storage
Tata Harrier:
- Longer wheelbase(2,741mm) →more legroom
- Boot space: 425 liters(slightly smaller than Hector)
- Good storage pockets(door bins, center console)
MG Hector:
- Slightly shorter wheelbase(2,750mm) butbetter rear knee room
- Boot space: 587 liters(larger than Harrier)
- More storage options(including under-seat storage)
Verdict: TheHector offers more boot space, while theHarrier has better rear legroom.
Noise, Vibration, and Harshness (NVH)
A quiet cabin enhances comfort, and both SUVs do well in this aspect.
Tata Harrier:
- Good sound insulation
- Engine noise is noticeable at high RPMs
- Less wind noisedue to aerodynamic design
MG Hector:
- Better NVH suppression
- Quieter cabindue to added insulation
- Minimal engine noise intrusion
Verdict: TheHector has a quieter cabin, making it more comfortable for highway cruising.
Conclusion
In terms of safety and comfort, the MG Hector and the Tata Harrierare both excellent options; yet, they appeal to significantly different desires. With a rating of five stars, the Harrier is the more secure option, while the Hector is associated with a higher level of technology and a more luxury ride. However, if you are more concerned with autonomous safety features, the Hector is the superior option. However, if safety in the event of a collision and comfort over long distances are of utmost importance, the Harrier is unrivaled.
.png)
.png)
.png)